TRUE CRIME ATLAS

Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Heist

Published September 21, 2026Updated October 28, 2026

Empty Frames

Crawlspace Media

Season 1 is about the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum heist: In the early hours of March 18th, 1990, two thieves posing as police officers were admitted into the Gardner Museum in Boston. In 81 minutes they stole 13 pieces of artwork, among the paintings stripped from their frames were works by Vermeer, Degas, and Rembrandt.... Show more

Open in Apple Podcasts
Episodes
  • Gardner Museum Heist — S1E4 - An Inside Angle
    Mar 20, 2018

    Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna interview Ulrich Boser about possible inside assistance and Bobby Donati’s interest in the eagle finial.

  • S2E6 - Gardner Heist Minutia
    Aug 20, 2019

    A discussion with the Muddy River Fact Checker about guard photographs and surveillance footage from the night before the theft.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — S3E21 - Geoffrey Kelly on Thirteen Perfect Fugitives
    Mar 17, 2026

    Retired FBI agent Geoffrey Kelly discusses his years investigating the theft and his book Thirteen Perfect Fugitives.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — S3E10 - Reporter Dennis House on Robert Gentile Interview
    Nov 17, 2021

    Reporter Dennis House discusses his interview with Robert Gentile and the investigation into possible possession of the missing art.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — S1E11 - The Turbo Plan
    Jun 27, 2018

    Paul Hendry discusses his proposed approach to recovering the missing Gardner artwork.

  • S1E12 - Gardner Heist Draft '18
    Jul 15, 2018

    The hosts compare proposed thieves, possible locations of the art and recovery leads.

Infamous America

Black Barrel Media

Historical True Crime — assassins, gangsters, mobsters and lawmen; manhunts, scandals and unexplained phenomena. Stories of the wildest and darkest chapters of America's past.

Open in Apple Podcasts
Episodes
  • BOSTON HEISTS Ep. 6 | Gardner Museum: “The Mafia Connection”
    Aug 27, 2025

    Part Six follows the investigation of Carmello Merlino’s associates and organized-crime connections to the missing art.

  • BOSTON HEISTS Ep. 3 | Gardner Museum: “You Can’t Sell A Rembrandt”
    Aug 6, 2025

    Part Three examines Boston art thefts before 1990, Myles Connor and earlier interest in the Gardner Museum.

  • BOSTON HEISTS Ep. 5 | Gardner Museum: “The Irish Connection”
    Aug 20, 2025

    Part Five follows early investigative leads involving Myles Connor, Whitey Bulger and Brian McDevitt.

Last Seen

A true-crime podcast about the most valuable — and confounding — art heist in history: the theft of 13 irreplaceable artworks from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston.

Open in Apple Podcasts
Episodes
  • Gardner Museum Heist — Episode 4: 'Two Bad Men'
    Oct 8, 2018

    Were George Reissfelder and David Turner involved in the Gardner heist?

  • Gardner Museum Heist — Episode 5: 'The Bobbys'
    Oct 15, 2018

    We trace the art's possible path from Boston to Connecticut to Philadelphia.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — Episode 1: '81 Minutes'
    Sep 16, 2018

    The opening episode reconstructs the thieves’ 81 minutes inside the museum.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — Episode 2: 'Inside Job?'
    Sep 24, 2018

    On the night of the heist, security guard Rick Abath made the critical mistake of letting the thieves into the museum. In this episode, we ask if it was indeed a mistake.

  • Gardner Museum Heist — Episode 3: 'Not A Bunch Of Jamokes'
    Oct 1, 2018

    Was the heist planned in the belly of Boston's criminal underworld operating out of a Dorchester auto body shop?

Stuff about Things: An Art History Podcast

Lindsay Sheedy

Hi! My name is Lindsay and I host Stuff about Things: An Art History Podcast.... Show more

Open in Apple Podcasts
Episodes
  • Episode 44: The Gardner Heist, Part I
    Jul 29, 2025

    Art historian Lindsay Sheedy reconstructs the break-in and 81-minute theft, then traces the immediate aftermath, principal investigative leads and frequently named suspects. The episode is the case-focused first half of a two-part treatment and draws on contemporary reporting, official records and major books about the heist.

  • Episode 45: The Gardner Heist, Part II
    Nov 1, 2025

    Art historian Lindsay Sheedy examines all 13 objects stolen from the Gardner Museum, explaining their histories, artistic significance and places within Isabella Stewart Gardner’s collection. This artwork-focused second installment complements Part I’s account of the theft and investigation.